Thomas Johnson
2014-08-29 21:52:05 UTC
I am trying to sort out a chicken-and-egg problem is probably more of a
network design question than bird-specific.
I am using bird to announce prefixes from two geographically-separate
locations (A and B). I am announcing different prefixes at each, but with
the same AS. The problem I am having is how to get these locations to add
each other's routes.
At location A, I have a pair of bird routers (X and Y), each connected to a
different provider. Both routers announce the prefixes for this site over
eBGP. These routers have an iBGP session between them.
At location B, there is a single router (Z), connected to one ISP. It
announces its own prefixes upstream.
Since both sites announce with the same AS, they don't import the other's
prefixes. An iBGP full-mesh seems to be the _correct_ solution, but I am
having trouble getting this implemented correctly.
If I configure the inter-site iBGP sessions to connect between the
addresses on the WAN interfaces, I get partial success. At site A, router X
correctly adds routes for site B. Router Y establishes a connection to
router Z (site B), but adds the B prefixes as unreachable. The difference
is that the Y->Z BGP connection (A->B direction) is routed via router X
(shorter AS path via X ISP). My configuration files for this setup are
below.
If I attempt to establish the inter-site iBGP between the loopbacks on the
routers, I have no success, since the loopback addresses fall with the
subnets I announce at each site.
Is there some bit of configuration I am missing? Am I going about this the
wrong way? Any thoughts are appreciated.
#
# router Y
# site A
#
protocol bgp bgp_he {
local as 12345;
neighbor 1.1.2.69 as 6939;
# Export exactly what prefixes we want advertised. No surprises.
export filter {
if proto = "static_bgp" then accept;
if proto = "portable_bgp" then accept;
reject;
};
# Import filtered routes from upstream.
import filter bgp_in_he;
}
protocol bgp ibgp_border {
local 6.9.5.212 as 12345;
neighbor 6.9.5.213 as 12345;
multihop 2;
import filter { accept; };
export filter {
if source != RTS_BGP then { reject; }
if proto = "ibgp_border" then { reject; }
accept;
};
}
protocol bgp ibgp_1b {
local 1.1.2.70 as 12345;
neighbor 7.4.2.132 as 12345;
multihop 10;
import filter { accept; };
export filter {
if proto = "static_bgp" then accept;
if proto = "portable_bgp" then accept;
reject;
};
}
protocol ospf {
# *snip*
}
#
# router X
# site A
#
protocol bgp bgp_cogent {
local as 12345;
neighbor 3.8.1.105 as 174;
# Export exactly what prefixes we want advertised. No surprises.
export filter {
if proto = "static_bgp" then accept;
if proto = "portable_bgp" && net.len <= 24 then accept;
reject;
};
# Import filtered routes from upstream.
import filter bgp_in_cogent;
}
protocol bgp ibgp_border {
local 6.9.5.213 as 12345;
neighbor 6.9.5.212 as 12345;
multihop 2;
# Send all routes learnt via BGP
import filter { accept; };
export filter {
if source != RTS_BGP then { reject; }
if proto = "ibgp_border" then { reject; }
accept;
};
}
protocol bgp ibgp_1b {
local 3.8.1.106 as 12345;
neighbor 7.4.2.132 as 12345;
multihop 10;
import filter { accept; };
export filter {
if proto = "static_bgp" then accept;
if proto = "portable_bgp" && net.len <= 24 then accept;
reject;
};
}
protocol ospf {
# *snip*
}
#
# router Z
# site B
#
template bgp ibgp_A {
debug all;
local 7.4.2.132 as 12345;
multihop 10;
import filter { accept; };
export filter {
if proto = "static_bgp" then accept;
if proto = "standby_bgp" then accept;
if proto = "portable_bgp" then accept;
reject;
};
}
protocol bgp ibgp_Y from ibgp_A { neighbor 1.1.2.70 as 12345; };
protocol bgp ibgp_X from ibgp_A { neighbor 3.8.1.106 as 12345; };
template bgp B {
# Set our local AS.
local as 12345;
# Export exactly what prefixes we want advertised. No surprises.
export filter {
if proto = "static_bgp" then accept;
if proto = "standby_bgp" then accept;
if proto = "portable_bgp" && net.len <= 24 then accept;
reject;
};
# Import filtered routes from upstream.
import filter bgp_in_B;
}
protocol bgp bgp_B from B { neighbor 7.4.2.130 as 1212; };
network design question than bird-specific.
I am using bird to announce prefixes from two geographically-separate
locations (A and B). I am announcing different prefixes at each, but with
the same AS. The problem I am having is how to get these locations to add
each other's routes.
At location A, I have a pair of bird routers (X and Y), each connected to a
different provider. Both routers announce the prefixes for this site over
eBGP. These routers have an iBGP session between them.
At location B, there is a single router (Z), connected to one ISP. It
announces its own prefixes upstream.
Since both sites announce with the same AS, they don't import the other's
prefixes. An iBGP full-mesh seems to be the _correct_ solution, but I am
having trouble getting this implemented correctly.
If I configure the inter-site iBGP sessions to connect between the
addresses on the WAN interfaces, I get partial success. At site A, router X
correctly adds routes for site B. Router Y establishes a connection to
router Z (site B), but adds the B prefixes as unreachable. The difference
is that the Y->Z BGP connection (A->B direction) is routed via router X
(shorter AS path via X ISP). My configuration files for this setup are
below.
If I attempt to establish the inter-site iBGP between the loopbacks on the
routers, I have no success, since the loopback addresses fall with the
subnets I announce at each site.
Is there some bit of configuration I am missing? Am I going about this the
wrong way? Any thoughts are appreciated.
#
# router Y
# site A
#
protocol bgp bgp_he {
local as 12345;
neighbor 1.1.2.69 as 6939;
# Export exactly what prefixes we want advertised. No surprises.
export filter {
if proto = "static_bgp" then accept;
if proto = "portable_bgp" then accept;
reject;
};
# Import filtered routes from upstream.
import filter bgp_in_he;
}
protocol bgp ibgp_border {
local 6.9.5.212 as 12345;
neighbor 6.9.5.213 as 12345;
multihop 2;
import filter { accept; };
export filter {
if source != RTS_BGP then { reject; }
if proto = "ibgp_border" then { reject; }
accept;
};
}
protocol bgp ibgp_1b {
local 1.1.2.70 as 12345;
neighbor 7.4.2.132 as 12345;
multihop 10;
import filter { accept; };
export filter {
if proto = "static_bgp" then accept;
if proto = "portable_bgp" then accept;
reject;
};
}
protocol ospf {
# *snip*
}
#
# router X
# site A
#
protocol bgp bgp_cogent {
local as 12345;
neighbor 3.8.1.105 as 174;
# Export exactly what prefixes we want advertised. No surprises.
export filter {
if proto = "static_bgp" then accept;
if proto = "portable_bgp" && net.len <= 24 then accept;
reject;
};
# Import filtered routes from upstream.
import filter bgp_in_cogent;
}
protocol bgp ibgp_border {
local 6.9.5.213 as 12345;
neighbor 6.9.5.212 as 12345;
multihop 2;
# Send all routes learnt via BGP
import filter { accept; };
export filter {
if source != RTS_BGP then { reject; }
if proto = "ibgp_border" then { reject; }
accept;
};
}
protocol bgp ibgp_1b {
local 3.8.1.106 as 12345;
neighbor 7.4.2.132 as 12345;
multihop 10;
import filter { accept; };
export filter {
if proto = "static_bgp" then accept;
if proto = "portable_bgp" && net.len <= 24 then accept;
reject;
};
}
protocol ospf {
# *snip*
}
#
# router Z
# site B
#
template bgp ibgp_A {
debug all;
local 7.4.2.132 as 12345;
multihop 10;
import filter { accept; };
export filter {
if proto = "static_bgp" then accept;
if proto = "standby_bgp" then accept;
if proto = "portable_bgp" then accept;
reject;
};
}
protocol bgp ibgp_Y from ibgp_A { neighbor 1.1.2.70 as 12345; };
protocol bgp ibgp_X from ibgp_A { neighbor 3.8.1.106 as 12345; };
template bgp B {
# Set our local AS.
local as 12345;
# Export exactly what prefixes we want advertised. No surprises.
export filter {
if proto = "static_bgp" then accept;
if proto = "standby_bgp" then accept;
if proto = "portable_bgp" && net.len <= 24 then accept;
reject;
};
# Import filtered routes from upstream.
import filter bgp_in_B;
}
protocol bgp bgp_B from B { neighbor 7.4.2.130 as 1212; };